SOUTHOLD    HISTORICAL     SOCIETY 

 Home | Feedback | Contents | Online Shop | Search

 North Fork Hotels  




Sign Up for News & Events


~ HOTELS & INNS OF SOUTHOLD TOWN ~

Compiled by Geoffrey K. Fleming & Amy Kasuga Folk, 2009

The table below contains a detailed listing of all known hotels and inns that exist or did exist within Southold Town (including Fisher's Island).  This research was created during the course of the work on the Society's book "Hotels & Inns of Long Island's North Fork," which was released by the History Press in the fall of 2009.  If you find errors, omissions, or wish to add or correct information, please email the Society. Thank you.  Updated 11/20/2012.

Name Village Owner Years Of Operation Address Location Of Items Name Changes Notes
A Walk in the Woods Bed & Breakfast Southold
 
In operation North Bayview Road SHS
 

 
Acorn Hollow Bed & Breakfast Southold Mary & Robert Skoblicki In operation Oaklawn Avenue SHS
 

 
Adams Boarding House Southold C Adams 1880's
 
SCHS
 

 
Albertson House Southold W C Albertson / W F Mitchell 1890s-1930? Main Road SHS / SCHS
 
Demolished 1955-1956
Andrew's Legacy Bed & Breakfast Peconic
 
c.2007-present Main Road SHS
 
Operated by descendants of the owner of the MacNish's Hotel
Arbor View House Bed & Breakfast East Marion Veda & Wilfred Joseph 1999-present
 
SHS
 

 
Arshamomaque Inn & Cottages Southold Bennett De Beixedon / Floyd King 1921-1941 Beixedon SHS
 
Destroyed by fire in July 1941
Asten Boarding House Southold J A Asten 1900's
 
SCHS
 

 
Atlantic Manor Boarding House Greenport George & Fannie Griffin 1910-1940's? Atlantic Avenue OHS
 

 
Aunt Dot's Victorian Bed & Breakfast East Marion
 
c2006-present Main Road SHS
 

 
Barth Hotel & Grill Greenport
 
1880-1959
 
Corwin
 
Taken down by the North Fork Wrecking Co.
Barth House Greenport George Barth 1900's
 
SCHS
 

 
Bartlett House Bed & Breakfast Greenport Linda & John Sabatino / Diane & Jack Gilmore 1980's-present
 
SHS
 

 
Bay Home Inn Southold / Peconic
 

 
S Harbor Lane
 
BH Farm
 
Bay House Orient Maria R. Merriman / Cicero Breeze King & son 1880's-1960's
 
OHS
 
Later it included cottages
Bayside Hotel South Jamesport B H Jones 1880's
 
SCHS
 

 
Bayview Cottage Mattituck F Bicking
 

 
SHS / Corwin
 

 
Bayview Cottages Mattituck Emilie Haunstetter / Kelly Navarra 1890s-? Bay Avenue SHS Mattituck Motel Later moved together to form the Mattituck Motel
Bayview Hotel South Jamesport John Trages / "Bob Patchell 1910's-present
 
SHS Bayview Inn Presently (2009) the Bayview Inn & Restaurant
Bayview Inn South Jamesport John Trages / "Bob Patchell 1910's-present
 
SHS Bayview Hotel
 
Beachcomber Resort Motel Cutchogue
 
1950's-1995 Duck Pond Road SHS Santorini Beachcomber
 
Beckwith Boarding House Southold Anna Beckwith 1900's Beckwith Avenue SCHS
 
Presently a doctor's office
Berry Boarding House Southold Mrs J Berry 1900's
 
SCHS
 

 
Betts Hotel Mattituck
 

 

 
Corwin
 

 
Betts Hotel Cutchogue   1900's Main Road & New Suffolk Road SHS & CL   Disassembled, only west section still stands on the site, other part became a house in New Suffolk
Blue Dolphin Resort East Marion
 
c1999-present
 

 
The Blue
 
Blue Heron's Nest Bed & Breakfast Cutchogue Rich Frerking 2007-present Lilac Lane SHS
 

 
Blue Iris Bed & Breakfast Cutchogue Lorry & Jerry Siani 2002-present
 
SHS
 

 
Booth House Southold Joseph C Booth 1877-?
 
SHS
 

 
Booth House Greenport
 
1877-1968 west of Ludlam Street OHS / SHS
 
Closed 1968, Burned 1971
Brick Cove Cabins Greenport
 
1940's-present Sage Boulevard SHS
 
Cottage colony
Brown Boarding House Orient Martha Brewer Brown /  W E Brown 1892-? Main Road OHS
 
Currently apartments
Brown House South Jamesport C W Conklin
 

 
LI Traveler Riverside Hotel
 
Burr Hotel Greenport F B Thornhill /  G P Salmon c.1870's-1894 Third Street SHS Sterlington Hotel Presently (2009) a restaurant
Burr House Greenport Mrs Burr 1880's
 
SCHS
 

 
By the Bluff Bed & Breakfast East Marion
 
In operation Rocky Point Road SHS
 

 
Carter Boarding house South Jamesport J H Carter 1900's
 
SCHS
 

 
Case Farm House Peconic Annie L Case 1900's
 
SCHS
 

 
Cedar Beach Inn Southold Edwin H. Brown / Eugene Sutherland c. 1915-2000 Main Bayview Road SHS General Wayne Inn Partially demolished
Chas J Hannaburg's Cutchogue Charles Hannaburg
 

 
SHS
 

 
Cherry Lane Boarding House Greenport Annie S Benjamin 1904-? Cherry Lane OHS
 
No longer standing
Clark House Greenport Betsey Clark / John Clarke / Maria Clarke 1831-1927 Main Street SHS / Corwin Clarke House Demolished in sections beginning in 1935
Clarke House Greenport Betsey Clark / John Clarke / Maria Clarke 1831-1927 Main Street SHS / Corwin Clark House Demolished in sections beginning in 1935
Colonial Inn Mattituck Tyson L Hamilton/Belle Wycoff Hamilton c1910-1940s
 
Love Lane & Rte 48 SHS
 
Burned in the late 1950s
 
Commerical Hotel Greenport M M Mott / Abraham Sully c1870-1910 Main Street SHS  / Corwin Claudio's Restaurant / Mott's Bayshore House Presently Claudios' Restaurant
Constant Booth Inn Greenport (Stirling) Constant Booth / Orange Webb c1750's-1800's Sterling (Stirling) Creek OHS Webb House Moved to Oysterponds Historical Society, Orient, in 1955
Conway Inn Southold John Lellman / Patrick Conway /  Mrs J Conway / Walter Clark / CE Katz / H W Knoxon 1869-1900's Horton Point SHS Horton Point House Hotel Partially demolished, remaining portion converted into a private home
Copps Boarding House Mattituck Mrs D A Copps 1880's
 
SCHS
 

 
Corey Boarding house Southold S B Corey 1880's
 
SCHS
 

 
Corwin Boarding House South Jamesport W H Corwin 1900's
 
SCHS
 

 
Corwin House New Suffolk A H Corwin 1900's
 
SCHS
 

 
Cox Boarding House Mattituck R Cox
 

 
SCHS
 

 
Cozee Cove Cottages & Motel East Marion
 
1950's-present
 
SHS
 

 
Crescent Beach Colony & Cottages East Marion
 
1965
 
SHS
 

 
Crown Prince Hotel Greenport F E Barth
 

 
SHS
 

 
Cutchogue House Cutchogue W E Gee
 

 
SHS
 

 
Dan Brown's Cabins East Marion Daniel Brown 1950's Rte 25 Corwin Hellenic Cabins / Dan Browns Cabins Originals demolished 2005?, replaced
Drossos Manor Motel Greenport Drossos Family 1950's-present Main Road Corwin / SHS
 
The largest building on the site burned in 1963
East of the Sun Bed & Breakfast Southold Dianne Danek In operation Great Pond Way SHS
 

 
Edward Brothers House Orient John Edwards 1870's-1886 Main Road OHS Seward House Currently a private home
Ellis House Bed & Breakfast Southold Connie & Scott Ellis 2004-present Main Road SHS
 

 
Elm Cottage Southold Mrs M Cleveland 1900's
 
SCHS
 

 
Eureka House Hotel Mattituck C MacMillan / C M Miller 1885-? Love Lane SHS
 
Building still stands
Ezra S Tillinghast Boarding House Southold Ezra Tillinghast 1889
 
SHS
 

 
Fairyland House Mattituck B G Tuthill
 

 
SCHS
 

 
Fanning Boarding House Cutchogue Foster R Fanning 1880's
 
SCHS
 

 
Fanning Farm New Suffolk Mrs W M Von Greiffenberg 1920's
 
SCHS
 

 
Farm House South Jamesport G C Hallock 1900's
 
SCHS
 

 
Farm House South Jamesport N Maher 1900's
 
SCHS
 

 
Farm House South Jamesport J H Youngs 1900's
 
SCHS
 

 
Fickeissen Farm Boarding House Southold F Fickeissen 1900's
 
SCHS
 

 
Fisher's Island Beach Hotel Fisher's Island
 

 

 
Internet
 

 
Fordham House Bed & Breakfast Greenport
 
In operation Main Street SHS
 

 
Freddy's House Bed & Breakfast Cutchogue Prudence Wickham & Dan Heston 1997 - present
 
SHS
 

 
Furey Farm Boarding House Southold Mrs W Furey 1900's
 
SCHS
 

 
Furey Farm Boarding House Southold Mrs M Furey 1900's
 
SCHS
 

 
Gardiner Farm Boarding House Southold WH Gardiner 1900's
 
SCHS
 

 
General Wayne Inn Southold Edwin H. Brown / Eugene Sutherland c. 1915-2000 Main Bayview Road SHS Cedar Beach Inn Partially demolished
Glenwood Hotel Mattituck John Zenzius / Clement MacMillan 1892-1962 Main Road SHS Glenwood Lodge Building restored in 2004
Glover Boarding House Orient C E Glover 1880's
 
SCHS
 

 
Gogarty Boarding House Southold E Fogarty 1880's
 
SCHS
 

 
Grant House New Suffolk William H. Grant c1880's-1900's
 
Internet MacNish's Hotel / New Suffolk Hotel Collapsed and demolished
Great Peconic Bay House South Jamesport Capt Edward Downs 1878-1952 South Jamesport Avenue SHS / OHS
 
Demolished late 1950's
Greenport House Greenport Charles H Koegel? 1900's Front Street & Main Street OHS / SHS / SCHS / Corwin Griffing House Hotel Dennis Operated through 1920's?
Greenporter Resort Motel Greenport Jack Levin c1957-present Front Street Corwin
 
Sold to Debra Rivera in 2000
Griffing House Greenport Louis Victory / James Y Wells / Charles H Koegel 1800's-1900's Front Street & Main Street OHS / SHS / SCHS / Corwin Hotel Dennis Greenport House Operated through 1920's?
Hallock Boarding House South Jamesport W L Hallock 1880's
 
SCHS
 

 
Harbor Front Inn Greenport Kace Development LLC 2007?-present Front Street SHS
 

 
Harbor Knoll Bed & Breakfast Greenport Leueen Miller 2001-present
 
SHS
 

 
Hazard Boarding House Mattituck Mrs R H Hazard 1880's
 
SCHS
 

 
Hedges Board House Greenport Edna & Henry Hedges 1900's Fourth Street Hedges
 
Specialized in renting to school teachers
Heffron Boarding House Cutchogue S Heffron 1880's
 
SCHS
 

 
Helen's Hotel Greenport
 
c1900-1960's Front Street SHS Vienna Hotel Helen's Hotel Currently the Rhumbline Restaurant
Hellenic Cottages East Marion
 
1950's Rte 25
 
Dan Brown's Cabins Originals demolished 2005?, replaced
Heron Harbor Suites Southold Lieblein family In operation Main Road SHS
 

 
Hill Side Cottage New Suffolk Mrs D M Goldsmith 1900's
 
SCHS
 

 
Holland House New Suffolk Henry Jacobs
 

 
SHS
 

 
Homeport Bed & Breakfast Peconic Cheryl & Peter Castiglione c2000-present Peconic Lane SHS
 

 
Homestead House East Marion
 

 

 

 

 

 
Hommel House Orient A W Hommel c1880's-1920's Village Lane OHS
 
1st structure burned in 1894 and was rebuilt
Horton Boarding House Cutchogue Mrs E E Horton 1880's
 
SCHS
 

 
Horton House New Suffolk Mrs H A Horton 1900's
 
SCHS
 

 
Horton Point House Hotel Southold John Lellman / Patrick Conway /  Mrs J Conway / Walter Clark / CE Katz / H W Knoxon 1869-1900's Horton Point SHS Conway Inn Partially demolished, remaining portion converted into a private home
Hotel Dennis Greenport Louis Victory 1900's Front Street & Main Street OHS / SHS / SCHS / Corwin Griffing House Greenport House Operated through 1920's?
Hotel Greenport Greenport Edward McComber c1900-1960's Front Street SHS Hotel Greenport Vienna Hotel Currently the Rhumbline Restaurant
Howard Farm House Cutchogue M H Howard 1900's
 
SCHS
 

 
Idlewild Hotel Southold Mrs F Maxwell
 
Frederick Maxwell property Internet
 

 
Idlewild House South Jamesport H Griffing Downs 1899
 
Brooklyn Eagle
 

 
Ingleside boardinghouse Mattituck S H Tuthill
 

 
Internet
 

 
J Baker Boarding House Greenport Joshua Baker
 
Third Street SHS
 

 
Jamesport Hotel South Jamesport James Tuthill 1838-1839
 
Brooklyn Eagle
 
On 12 lots
Jamesport Manor Inn South Jamesport
 
1930's-present
 
SHS
 
Associated with Prohibition, badly damaged by fire & rebuilt, 2007
Jennings Boarding House Cutchogue Capt Jonathan Jennings 1880's
 
SCHS
 

 
Jewell Farm House Southold E F Jewell 1880's /  1900's
 
SCHS
 

 
Judd's Hotel Southold Frank L. Judd 1870's-1880's Main Road & corner of Youngs Avenue SHS Southold Hotel Cut up into pieces and sold, several portions still extant as private homes
Kreutzer Park Hotel Southold Mrs Marie Kreutzer c1890's-1919 Main Road SHS Also listed under name Kientzer Moved to water & converted to a private home by the Lange family
Lake Lodge Peconic
 

 

 
SHS
 
Associated with Prohibition
Laura's Cabin on the Green East Marion
 

 

 

 

 

 
Laurel House Laurel Miss H L Fanning
 

 
SCHS
 

 
Laurel House Southold Mrs George L Gaffga 1920's
 
SHS
 

 
Lehr Farm House Southold Martin Lehr 1900's
 
SCHS
 

 
Leicht Farm House Southold C Leicht 1900's
 
SCHS
 

 
Lewis Boarding House Southold Mrs Carrie J Lewis 1900's Main Road SHS / SCHS
 
Later owned by Cochran family, demolished 1989.
Locust Grove Hotel South Jamesport James L Downs /  E O Downs 1899-1920? South Jamesport Avenue Brooklyn Eagle Waters Edge Hotel New House 100ft from Peconic Bay, partially demolished for the Motel on the Bay
Lyle's Beach Hotel (or Lyles) Fisher's Island Walker & William Hoes 1882-1891
 
Internet Munnatawket Hotel Rebuilt 1891, demolished 1926
MacNish's Hotel New Suffolk William McNish/Walter MacNish / William H. Grant c1880's-1900's
 
SHS New Suffolk Hotel / Grant Hotel Collapsed and demolished
Mallard Inn East Marion
 
1940's-? Main Road
 

 
Located at the Causeway, burned 1974-1976
Manaton House Greenport Mrs W P Manaton 1920's
 
SHS
 

 
Mansion House Fisher's Island Edmund & Walter Ferguson 1892-1941
 
SHS
 
Partially demolished c1945
Mattituck Harbor Inn Mattituck Hubert W Klein / Andrew Barbi / Eugenia Sommerman / Mrs A Esposito / M L Gardoni c1880's-1938 Breezy Point SHS
 
Destroyed by fire in 1938 Richaret & Vicing Pamphlet
Mattituck House Mattituck Riley Brothers / William Niederstein / George Blake / Edith Peyton / Carl Dahl / GM Betts / Albert E Dantzig 1700's-1950's Love Lane & Old Sound Avenue SHS / LI Traveler Niederstein's Mattituck House Demolished 1950's
Mattituck Motel Mattituck Emilie Haunstetter / Kelly Navarra 1950's-present Bay Avenue SHS
 
Started out as the Bay View Cottages c1890's
McCabe Farm House Southold M McCabe 1900's
 
SCHS
 

 
Meadow Pink Cottage Peconic J Ducey 1900's
 
SCHS
 

 
Miamogue Hotel South Jamesport I. Seymour Corwin 1875-1932 South Jamesport Avenue SHS
 
1st hotel destroyed by fire in 1895, replacement destroyed by fire in 1932
Mononotto Inn Fisher's Island Maria Hoppes 1892-1939
 
SHS
 
Demolished 1939
Moore Boarding House Greenport Mrs C B Moore 1900's
 
SCHS
 

 
Moore's hotel Southold
 

 
J W Huntting property Internet
 

 
Moore's Tavern Southold Mrs. Moore c1730's-1800's Boisseau Avenue & Main Road SHS
 
One of the earliest recorded inns, demolished in 1936
Morse Boarding House South Jamesport B H Morse 1880's
 
SCHS
 

 
Mossback Cabins East Marion Mossback family
 
Main Road OHS
 
Related to the family of noted painter Charles Henry Miller
Motel on the Bay South Jamesport Bob Patchell c1950s-present
 
SHS
 
Located on the site of the former Waters Edge Hotel
Mott's Bayshore House Greenport M M Mott c1890-1910 Main Street SHS  / Corwin Claudio's Restaurant
 
Mount Pleasant House Hotel Orient William & Samuel Young / John & Joseph Miller 1879-1940's
 
OHS / SHS Mount Pleasant Hotel Demolished 1940's
Mrs Albert Smith Boarding House Mattituck Mrs Albert Smith
 

 
SHS
 

 
Mrs Joseph A McDonald Boarding House Greenport Mrs Joseph McDonald (Sara)
 
Ludlum Place SHS
 

 
Mrs O Smith Boarding House Greenport Mrs O Smith (widow)
 
Central Avenue SHS
 

 
Mrs S Davis Boarding House Southold Mrs S Davis
 

 
SHS
 

 
Mrs Seaman Boarding House Greenport Mrs Seaman (Annie?)
 
Second Street SHS
 

 
Mrs Wm Payne Boarding House Greenport Mrs William H Payne
 
Central Avenue SHS
 

 
Munnatawket Hotel Fisher's Island Edmund & Walter Ferguson 1891-1926
 
SHS Lyle's Beach Hotel Demolished 1926
Nassau Point Club Hotel Nassau Point
 
1903-1928
 
SHS
 
Burned June 18, 1928
New Suffolk Hotel New Suffolk William MacNish/Walter MacNish / William H. Grant c1880's-1900's
 
SHS MacNish's Hotel / Grant Hotel Collapsed and demolished
Niederstein's Mattituck House Mattituck William Niederstein 1700's-1950's Love Lane & Old Sound Avenue SHS Mattituck House Demolished 1950's
North Fork Motel Southold Laasko Brothers 1950's Rte 48 & Old North Road Corwin / SHS North Fork Condominiums Two story, 43 rooms
Occidental House Greenport George Davis / Frank Smith / Lewis Laws 1895
 
LI Traveler
 

 
Old Glory House Greenport Frank J Claudio 1900's Main Road Corwin
 

 
Old Mill Mattituck Adolf Magdefrau
 

 
SHS
 
Associated with Prohibition, at one time it had guest rooms
Old Orchard Farm Southold G R Jennings 1900's
 
SCHS
 

 
O'Neill Cottage Southold Hannah O'Neill
 

 
SCHS
 

 
Orient Inn Bed & Breakfast Orient Joan Turturro & Howard Leshaw 1990's?-present Main Road SHS
 

 
Orient Point House Orient Jonathan F Latham / Merry Parsons 1834-1950's Main Road SHS / OHS Orient Point Inn Demolished 1980's-1990's
Orient Point Inn Orient Jonathan F Latham / Merry Parsons 1834-1950's Main Road SHS / OHS Orient Point House Demolished 1980's-1990's
Paradise Point Southold George W Bullock (Bullick)
 

 
SHS / OHS
 

 
Paragon Hotel Greenport J J Burns
 

 
SHS
 

 
Paumanok Inn Southold George F Hummel / W J Palmer c1910-1925 Lighthouse Road SHS Soundview House Demolished
Payne Boarding House Southold B T Payne / B J Payne 1900's
 
SCHS
 

 
Peakin's Tavern Orient John Peakin 1700's
 
OHS
 

 
Peconic Bay House Greenport John Webb / F B Goldsmith / L O Richardson /  Augustus Smith 1845-1900's Third Street & Front Street SHS / Corwin Peconic House Demolished before 1930
Peconic House Greenport John Webb / F B Goldsmith / L O Richardson /  Augustus Smith 1845-1900's Third Street & Front Street SHS / Corwin Peconic Bay House Demolished before 1930
Peconic Park Hotel Nassau Point Mr. Wilson 1883
 
SHS
 
* Proposed, but never constructed
Phillips Boarding House Southold G W Phillips 1880's
 
SCHS
 

 
Pipes Neck House Greenport Mrs A C Corwin / Mary Holman / Isadora Judge 1823-1940's
 
OHS
 
Original burned in 1912 and was rebuilt
PJ Claudio Greenport PJ Claudio
 

 
SHS
 

 
Pleasant View Cottages Greenport
 
1950's-present Seventh Street SHS
 

 
Point O'View Inn Southold J. Payne / Anna Walsh / Polliwater 1920's-1940's 54775 Main Road SHS
 
Currently a private home
Prince Boarding House Peconic G H Prince 1900's
 
SCHS
 

 
Prince Boarding House Southold B L Prince 1880's
 
SCHS
 

 
Quintessentials Bed & Breakfast East Marion Sylvia Daley 1994-present
 
SHS
 

 
Reeves Boarding House Greenport Mrs W W Reeves 1880's
 
SCHS
 

 
Richmond Farm House Southold HC Richmond 1900's
 
SCHS
 

 
Riverside Hotel South Jamesport C W Conklin
 

 
LI Traveler Brown House
 
Roarke Boarding House Southold P Roarke 1880's
 
SCHS
 

 
Robinson Boarding House South Jamesport J F Robinson 1880's
 
SCHS
 

 
Rocky Bluff Inn Greenport Mrs. Charles Herman c. 1906 North Road PC   No longer extant
Rooming House Southold Etta Payne / Catheryn McCabe
 

 
Murphy
 
Ms McCabe also housekeeper to Priests at St Patricks Church
S Tuthill Boarding House Mattituck
 

 

 
SHS
 

 
Santorini Beachcomber Cutchogue Santorini family 1995-present Duck Pond Road SHS Beachcomber Resort Motel
 
Seward House Orient
 
1870's-1886 Main Road OHS Edward Brothers House Currently a private home
Shady Point Hotel Mattituck W S Du Bois 1895
 
LI Traveler Internet
 

 
Shorecrest Bed & Breakfast Greenport Susan & John Barnes c2001-present Rte 48 SHS
 

 
Silver Sands Motel Greenport
 
c1958-present Silvermere Road SHS
 
Added to the Silvermere Bungalows site
Silvermere Bungalows Greenport
 
c1930's-present Silvermere Road SHS
 
Later joined by the Silver Sands Motel
Sound Shore Motel Greenport Jack & Irving Levin 1952-present Rte 48 SHS / Corwin Soundview Motel, Soundview Inn Still operated by the Levin family
Sound Shore Resort Motel Greenport Jack & Irving Levin 1952-present Rte 48 SHS / Corwin Soundview Motel, Soundview Inn Still operated by the Levin family
Sound View Farm House Cutchogue PJ Mahoney
 

 
Brooklyn Eagle
 

 
Soundview House Southold George F Hummel / W J Palmer c1910-1925 Lighthouse Road SHS Paumanok Inn Demolished
Soundview Inn Greenport Jack & Irving Levin 1952-present Rte 48 SHS / Corwin Sound Shore Resort Motel, Soundview Inn Still operated by the Levin family
Soundview Motel Greenport Jack & Irving Levin 1952-present Rte 48 SHS / Corwin Soundview Motel, Sound Shore Resort Hotel Still operated by the Levin family
Southold Beach Motel Southold Helmut Haas c1955-present Rte 48, Southold SHS Southold Town Beach Motel Sold to Amy Uyanik in 2005
Southold Hotel Southold William H Wells /  Joseph A Wells / Theodore Hoinkis / Frank L Judd / William W Sands / W Bassett / Charles Hannaburg / Abram W Kent /  J Stephens 1887 1830's-1920's Main Road & corner of Youngs Avenue SHS Judd's Hotel Cut up into pieces and sold, several portions still extant as private homes
Southold Inn Southold
 
c1910-present Main Road SHS Sunrise Inn / Southold Inn / La Gazelle / Coeur Des Vignes Currently North Fork Table & Inn
Southold Town Beach Motel Southold Helmut Haas c1955-present Rte 48, Southold SHS Southold Beach Motel Sold to Amy Uyanik in 2005
Sparks Boarding House South Jamesport Sparks 1880's
 
SCHS
 

 
Spruce Park Boarding House Southold Israel Peck 1850's Wells Avenue & Main Road SHS Oaklawn Demolished April 1966
Star House Greenport Manuel Claudio c1910
 
SHS
 

 
Star Inn & Cottages East Marion
 
c1950's-present Main Road
 

 
Across from East Marion Community Church
Sterling Harbor House Bed & Breakfast Greenport
 
In operation Sterling Street SHS
 

 
Sterling House Bed & Breakfast Greenport
 
In operation Bay Avenue SHS
 

 
Sterlington Hotel Greenport F B Thornhill /  G P Salmon 1894-1980? Third Street SHS Burr Hotel Presently (2009) a restaurant
Suffolk House New Suffolk Henry Burns
 

 
SHS
 

 
Sunrise Hotel Southold
 
c1910-present Main Road SHS Sunrise Inn / Southold Inn / La Gazelle / Coeur Des Vignes Currently North Fork Table & Inn
Sunrise Inn Southold
 
c1910-present Main Road SHS Sunrise Hotel / Southold Inn / La Gazelle / Coeur Des Vignes Currently North Fork Table & Inn
Sunrise Trail House Southold V & I Fitall
 

 
SCHS
 

 
Sunset Motel Greenport Molin Brothers / Vera Molin / Donna Levin c1960-present Rte 48 SHS
 
Presently (2009) operated by Martha Levin
The Country House Bed & Breakfast Cutchogue Noreen & Martin Frey In operation Skunk Lane SHS
 

 
The Harvest Inn Peconic Darolyn & Christopher ? 2002-present Main Road SHS
 

 
The Morning Glory Bed & Breakfast Greenport Renate & Klaus Wilhelm 2004-present Main Street SHS
 
House built in 1822
The Rhinelander Bed & Breakfast Cutchogue Gisela Morchel 1996-present Main Road SHS
 

 
The Victorian Lady Greenport
 
In operation Bay Avenue SHS
 

 
Tillinghast Boarding House Southold E S Tillinghast 1880's
 
SCHS
 

 
Timson Boarding House Greenport Mrs James Timson 1880's
 
SCHS
 
Possibly same as Timson Hotel
Timson Hotel Greenport James Timson 1869-1891 Main Street SHS / Corwin
 
Later George Flack decorating & Everett Warner Picture Frames
Top 'O the Mornin' Bed & Breakfast Cutchogue
 
In operation Main Road SHS
 

 
Townsend Boarding House Greenport Mrs S H Townsend 1880's
 
SCHS
 

 
Townsend Manor Inn Greenport Lillian Cook Townsend 1925-present Main Street SHS / OHS
 
Built as a residence for George Cogswell
Tuthill Boarding House Cutchogue H H Tuthill 1880's
 
SCHS
 

 
Tuthill Boarding House Cutchogue Ira B Tuthill 1880's
 
SCHS
 

 
Tuthill Boarding House Cutchogue G Tuthill 1880's
 
SCHS
 

 
Tuthill Boarding House Cutchogue H B Tuthill 1880's
 
SCHS
 

 
Tuthill Boarding House Cutchogue Mrs J G Tuthill 1880's
 
SCHS
 

 
Tuthill Boarding House Cutchogue O H Tuthill 1880's
 
SCHS
 

 
Tuthill Boarding House Mattituck Mrs Mavin Tuthill 1880's
 
SCHS
 

 
Tuthill Boarding House Southold W H Tuthill 1880's
 
SCHS
 

 
Tyler Boarding House South Jamesport H L Tyler 1900's
 
SCHS
 

 
Vail Boarding House Greenport G H Vail
 

 
SCHS
 

 
Vail Boarding House Southold W B Vail 1880's
 
SCHS
 

 
Victoria Motel & Cottages Southold
 
c1950's-1984 Main Bayview Road SHS
 
Demolished in 1984 and replaced by "The Cove Condominiums"
Vienna Hotel Greenport Stephan Cvija c1900-1960's Front Street SHS Hotel Greenport Helen's Hotel Currently the Rhumbline Restaurant
Village House Orient Jeremiah Vail 1880's-? Village Lane OHS Village Hotel Currently owned by Oysterponds Historical Society
Vintage Bed & Breakfast Cutchogue Jeanne & Lou Genovese 2000-present Skunk Lane SHS
 

 
Waters Edge Hotel South Jamesport E O Downs 1920-1940's?
 
SHS- Riverhead Halcyon days Locust Grove Hotel
 
White Lions Inn Greenport
 

 

 
SHS
 

 
White Shingles Boarding House Orient Hortense Knox 1930's-1953 Main Road OHS
 
Currently a private home
Wiggins Boarding House Greenport MV Wiggins
 

 
SCHS
 

 
Willow Cottage Southold Mrs E Davis 1900's
 
SCHS
 

 
Windamere Boarding House Mattituck HW Klein 1900's
 
SCHS / Internet
 

 
Winward Shore Motel & Cottage Greenport
 

 

 
SHS
 

 
Wyandank Hotel Greenport Charles C Wright / S P Conklin / Ansel V Young / F J CorwinHenry Stratton 1840-1968 Railroad Avenue SHS / OHS Wyandank House Demolished 1968. David Taylor
Yetter's hotel Greenport John Yetter
 

 
Internet
 

 
Youngs House Greenport Mrs L J Young
 

 
SHS
 

 

 

 

Southold Historical Society

P.O. Box 1, Southold, NY 11971  /  631-765-5500 / Fax  631-765-8510    

Send mail to shsdirec@optonline.net with questions or comments about this web site. Copyright 2003 Southold Historical Society   Last modified: 07/01/08

Website by Schuyler Horton & North Fork Internet