The table below contains a detailed listing of all
known hotels and inns that exist or did exist within
Southold Town (including Fisher's Island). This
research was created during the course of the work on
the Society's book "Hotels
& Inns of Long Island's North Fork," which
was released by the History Press in the fall of 2009.
If you find errors, omissions, or wish to add or
correct information, please email the Society. Thank
you. Updated 11/20/2012.
|
Name |
Village |
Owner |
Years Of Operation |
Address |
Location Of Items |
Name Changes |
Notes |
|
A Walk in the
Woods Bed & Breakfast |
Southold |
|
In operation |
North Bayview
Road |
SHS |
|
|
|
Acorn Hollow
Bed & Breakfast |
Southold |
Mary & Robert
Skoblicki |
In operation |
Oaklawn
Avenue |
SHS |
|
|
|
Adams
Boarding House |
Southold |
C Adams |
1880's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Albertson
House |
Southold |
W C
Albertson / W F Mitchell |
1890s-1930? |
Main Road |
SHS / SCHS |
|
Demolished
1955-1956 |
|
Andrew's
Legacy Bed & Breakfast |
Peconic |
|
c.2007-present |
Main Road |
SHS |
|
Operated by
descendants of the owner of the MacNish's Hotel |
|
Arbor View
House Bed & Breakfast |
East Marion |
Veda &
Wilfred Joseph |
1999-present |
|
SHS |
|
|
|
Arshamomaque
Inn & Cottages |
Southold |
Bennett De
Beixedon / Floyd King |
1921-1941 |
Beixedon |
SHS |
|
Destroyed by
fire in July 1941 |
|
Asten
Boarding House |
Southold |
J A Asten |
1900's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Atlantic
Manor Boarding House |
Greenport |
George &
Fannie Griffin |
1910-1940's? |
Atlantic
Avenue |
OHS |
|
|
|
Aunt Dot's
Victorian Bed & Breakfast |
East Marion |
|
c2006-present |
Main Road |
SHS |
|
|
|
Barth Hotel &
Grill |
Greenport |
|
1880-1959 |
|
Corwin |
|
Taken down by
the North Fork Wrecking Co. |
|
Barth House |
Greenport |
George Barth |
1900's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Bartlett
House Bed & Breakfast |
Greenport |
Linda & John
Sabatino / Diane & Jack Gilmore |
1980's-present |
|
SHS |
|
|
|
Bay Home Inn |
Southold / Peconic |
|
|
S Harbor Lane |
|
BH Farm |
|
|
Bay House |
Orient |
Maria R.
Merriman / Cicero Breeze King & son |
1880's-1960's |
|
OHS |
|
Later it
included cottages |
|
Bayside Hotel |
South
Jamesport |
B H Jones |
1880's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Bayview
Cottage |
Mattituck |
F Bicking |
|
|
SHS / Corwin
|
|
|
|
Bayview
Cottages |
Mattituck |
Emilie
Haunstetter / Kelly Navarra |
1890s-? |
Bay Avenue |
SHS |
Mattituck
Motel |
Later moved
together to form the Mattituck Motel |
|
Bayview Hotel |
South
Jamesport |
John
Trages / "Bob Patchell |
1910's-present |
|
SHS |
Bayview Inn |
Presently
(2009) the Bayview Inn & Restaurant |
|
Bayview Inn |
South
Jamesport |
John
Trages / "Bob Patchell |
1910's-present |
|
SHS |
Bayview Hotel |
|
|
Beachcomber
Resort Motel |
Cutchogue |
|
1950's-1995 |
Duck Pond
Road |
SHS |
Santorini
Beachcomber |
|
|
Beckwith
Boarding House |
Southold |
Anna Beckwith |
1900's |
Beckwith
Avenue |
SCHS |
|
Presently a
doctor's office |
|
Berry
Boarding House |
Southold |
Mrs J Berry |
1900's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Betts Hotel |
Mattituck |
|
|
|
Corwin |
|
|
|
Betts Hotel |
Cutchogue |
|
1900's |
Main Road & New Suffolk Road |
SHS & CL |
|
Disassembled, only west section still stands
on the site, other part became a house in New Suffolk |
|
Blue Dolphin
Resort |
East Marion |
|
c1999-present |
|
|
The Blue |
|
|
Blue Heron's
Nest Bed & Breakfast |
Cutchogue |
Rich Frerking |
2007-present |
Lilac Lane |
SHS |
|
|
|
Blue Iris Bed
& Breakfast |
Cutchogue |
Lorry & Jerry
Siani |
2002-present |
|
SHS |
|
|
|
Booth House |
Southold |
Joseph C
Booth |
1877-? |
|
SHS |
|
|
|
Booth House
|
Greenport |
|
1877-1968 |
west of
Ludlam Street |
OHS / SHS |
|
Closed 1968,
Burned 1971 |
|
Brick Cove
Cabins |
Greenport |
|
1940's-present |
Sage
Boulevard |
SHS |
|
Cottage
colony |
|
Brown
Boarding House |
Orient |
Martha Brewer
Brown / W E Brown |
1892-? |
Main Road |
OHS |
|
Currently
apartments |
|
Brown House |
South
Jamesport |
C W Conklin |
|
|
LI Traveler |
Riverside
Hotel |
|
|
Burr Hotel |
Greenport |
F B
Thornhill / G P Salmon |
c.1870's-1894 |
Third Street |
SHS |
Sterlington
Hotel |
Presently
(2009) a restaurant |
|
Burr House |
Greenport |
Mrs Burr |
1880's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
By the Bluff
Bed & Breakfast |
East Marion |
|
In operation |
Rocky Point
Road |
SHS |
|
|
|
Carter
Boarding house |
South
Jamesport |
J H Carter |
1900's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Case Farm
House |
Peconic |
Annie L Case |
1900's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Cedar Beach
Inn |
Southold |
Edwin H.
Brown / Eugene Sutherland |
c. 1915-2000 |
Main Bayview
Road |
SHS |
General Wayne
Inn |
Partially
demolished |
|
Chas J
Hannaburg's |
Cutchogue |
Charles
Hannaburg |
|
|
SHS |
|
|
|
Cherry Lane
Boarding House |
Greenport |
Annie S
Benjamin |
1904-? |
Cherry Lane |
OHS |
|
No longer
standing |
|
Clark House |
Greenport |
Betsey
Clark / John Clarke / Maria Clarke |
1831-1927 |
Main Street |
SHS / Corwin |
Clarke House |
Demolished in
sections beginning in 1935 |
|
Clarke House |
Greenport |
Betsey
Clark / John Clarke / Maria Clarke |
1831-1927 |
Main Street |
SHS / Corwin |
Clark House |
Demolished in
sections beginning in 1935 |
|
Colonial Inn |
Mattituck |
Tyson L
Hamilton/Belle Wycoff Hamilton |
c1910-1940s
|
Love Lane & Rte 48 |
SHS |
|
Burned in the late 1950s
|
|
Commerical
Hotel |
Greenport |
M M
Mott / Abraham Sully |
c1870-1910 |
Main Street |
SHS / Corwin
|
Claudio's
Restaurant / Mott's Bayshore House |
Presently
Claudios' Restaurant |
|
Constant
Booth Inn |
Greenport
(Stirling) |
Constant
Booth / Orange Webb |
c1750's-1800's |
Sterling
(Stirling) Creek |
OHS |
Webb House |
Moved to
Oysterponds Historical Society, Orient, in 1955 |
|
Conway Inn |
Southold |
John
Lellman / Patrick Conway / Mrs J Conway / Walter Clark / CE Katz / H W Knoxon |
1869-1900's |
Horton Point |
SHS |
Horton Point
House Hotel |
Partially
demolished, remaining portion converted into a private home |
|
Copps
Boarding House |
Mattituck |
Mrs D A Copps |
1880's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Corey
Boarding house |
Southold |
S B Corey |
1880's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Corwin
Boarding House |
South
Jamesport |
W H Corwin |
1900's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Corwin House |
New Suffolk |
A H Corwin |
1900's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Cox Boarding
House |
Mattituck |
R Cox |
|
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Cozee Cove
Cottages & Motel |
East Marion |
|
1950's-present |
|
SHS |
|
|
|
Crescent
Beach Colony & Cottages |
East Marion |
|
1965 |
|
SHS |
|
|
|
Crown Prince
Hotel |
Greenport |
F E Barth |
|
|
SHS |
|
|
|
Cutchogue
House |
Cutchogue |
W E Gee |
|
|
SHS
|
|
|
|
Dan Brown's
Cabins |
East Marion |
Daniel Brown |
1950's |
Rte 25 |
Corwin
|
Hellenic
Cabins / Dan Browns Cabins |
Originals
demolished 2005?, replaced |
|
Drossos Manor
Motel |
Greenport |
Drossos
Family |
1950's-present |
Main Road |
Corwin / SHS |
|
The largest
building on the site burned in 1963 |
|
East of the
Sun Bed & Breakfast |
Southold |
Dianne Danek |
In operation |
Great Pond
Way |
SHS |
|
|
|
Edward
Brothers House |
Orient |
John Edwards |
1870's-1886 |
Main Road |
OHS |
Seward House |
Currently a
private home |
|
Ellis House
Bed & Breakfast |
Southold |
Connie &
Scott Ellis |
2004-present |
Main Road |
SHS |
|
|
|
Elm Cottage |
Southold |
Mrs M
Cleveland |
1900's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Eureka House
Hotel |
Mattituck |
C MacMillan / C
M Miller |
1885-? |
Love Lane |
SHS |
|
Building
still stands |
|
Ezra S
Tillinghast Boarding House |
Southold |
Ezra
Tillinghast |
1889 |
|
SHS |
|
|
|
Fairyland
House |
Mattituck |
B G Tuthill |
|
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Fanning
Boarding House |
Cutchogue |
Foster R
Fanning |
1880's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Fanning Farm |
New Suffolk |
Mrs W M Von
Greiffenberg |
1920's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Farm House |
South
Jamesport |
G C Hallock |
1900's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Farm House |
South
Jamesport |
N Maher |
1900's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Farm House |
South
Jamesport |
J H Youngs |
1900's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Fickeissen
Farm Boarding House |
Southold |
F Fickeissen |
1900's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Fisher's
Island Beach Hotel |
Fisher's
Island |
|
|
|
Internet
|
|
|
|
Fordham House
Bed & Breakfast |
Greenport |
|
In operation |
Main Street |
SHS |
|
|
|
Freddy's
House Bed & Breakfast |
Cutchogue |
Prudence
Wickham & Dan Heston |
1997 -
present |
|
SHS |
|
|
|
Furey Farm
Boarding House |
Southold |
Mrs W Furey |
1900's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Furey Farm
Boarding House |
Southold |
Mrs M Furey |
1900's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Gardiner Farm
Boarding House |
Southold |
WH Gardiner |
1900's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
General Wayne
Inn |
Southold |
Edwin H.
Brown / Eugene Sutherland |
c. 1915-2000 |
Main Bayview
Road |
SHS |
Cedar Beach
Inn |
Partially
demolished |
|
Glenwood
Hotel |
Mattituck |
John
Zenzius / Clement MacMillan |
1892-1962 |
Main Road |
SHS |
Glenwood
Lodge |
Building
restored in 2004 |
|
Glover
Boarding House |
Orient |
C E Glover |
1880's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Gogarty
Boarding House |
Southold |
E Fogarty |
1880's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Grant House |
New Suffolk |
William H.
Grant |
c1880's-1900's |
|
Internet |
MacNish's
Hotel / New Suffolk Hotel |
Collapsed and
demolished |
|
Great Peconic
Bay House |
South
Jamesport |
Capt Edward
Downs |
1878-1952 |
South
Jamesport Avenue |
SHS / OHS |
|
Demolished
late 1950's |
|
Greenport
House |
Greenport |
Charles H
Koegel? |
1900's |
Front Street
& Main Street |
OHS / SHS / SCHS / Corwin |
Griffing
House Hotel Dennis |
Operated
through 1920's? |
|
Greenporter
Resort Motel |
Greenport |
Jack Levin |
c1957-present |
Front Street |
Corwin |
|
Sold to Debra
Rivera in 2000 |
|
Griffing
House |
Greenport |
Louis
Victory / James Y Wells / Charles H Koegel |
1800's-1900's |
Front Street
& Main Street |
OHS / SHS / SCHS / Corwin |
Hotel Dennis
Greenport House |
Operated
through 1920's? |
|
Hallock
Boarding House |
South
Jamesport |
W L Hallock |
1880's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Harbor Front
Inn |
Greenport |
Kace
Development LLC |
2007?-present |
Front Street |
SHS |
|
|
|
Harbor Knoll
Bed & Breakfast |
Greenport |
Leueen Miller |
2001-present |
|
SHS |
|
|
|
Hazard
Boarding House |
Mattituck |
Mrs R H
Hazard |
1880's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Hedges Board
House |
Greenport |
Edna & Henry
Hedges |
1900's |
Fourth Street |
Hedges |
|
Specialized
in renting to school teachers |
|
Heffron
Boarding House |
Cutchogue |
S Heffron |
1880's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Helen's Hotel |
Greenport |
|
c1900-1960's |
Front Street |
SHS |
Vienna Hotel
Helen's Hotel |
Currently the
Rhumbline Restaurant |
|
Hellenic
Cottages |
East Marion |
|
1950's |
Rte 25 |
|
Dan Brown's
Cabins |
Originals
demolished 2005?, replaced |
|
Heron Harbor
Suites |
Southold |
Lieblein
family |
In operation |
Main Road |
SHS |
|
|
|
Hill Side
Cottage |
New Suffolk |
Mrs D M
Goldsmith |
1900's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Holland House |
New Suffolk |
Henry Jacobs |
|
|
SHS |
|
|
|
Homeport Bed
& Breakfast |
Peconic |
Cheryl &
Peter Castiglione |
c2000-present |
Peconic Lane |
SHS |
|
|
|
Homestead
House |
East Marion |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Hommel House |
Orient |
A W Hommel |
c1880's-1920's |
Village Lane |
OHS |
|
1st structure
burned in 1894 and was rebuilt |
|
Horton
Boarding House |
Cutchogue |
Mrs E E
Horton |
1880's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Horton House |
New Suffolk |
Mrs H A
Horton |
1900's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Horton Point
House Hotel |
Southold |
John
Lellman / Patrick Conway / Mrs J Conway / Walter Clark / CE Katz / H W Knoxon |
1869-1900's |
Horton Point |
SHS |
Conway Inn |
Partially
demolished, remaining portion converted into a private home |
|
Hotel Dennis |
Greenport |
Louis Victory |
1900's |
Front Street
& Main Street |
OHS / SHS / SCHS / Corwin |
Griffing
House Greenport House |
Operated
through 1920's? |
|
Hotel
Greenport |
Greenport |
Edward
McComber |
c1900-1960's |
Front Street |
SHS |
Hotel
Greenport Vienna Hotel |
Currently the
Rhumbline Restaurant |
|
Howard Farm
House |
Cutchogue |
M H Howard |
1900's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Idlewild
Hotel |
Southold |
Mrs F Maxwell |
|
Frederick
Maxwell property |
Internet
|
|
|
|
Idlewild
House |
South
Jamesport |
H Griffing
Downs |
1899 |
|
Brooklyn
Eagle |
|
|
|
Ingleside
boardinghouse |
Mattituck |
S H Tuthill |
|
|
Internet
|
|
|
|
J Baker
Boarding House |
Greenport |
Joshua Baker |
|
Third Street |
SHS |
|
|
|
Jamesport
Hotel |
South
Jamesport |
James Tuthill |
1838-1839 |
|
Brooklyn
Eagle |
|
On 12 lots |
|
Jamesport
Manor Inn |
South
Jamesport |
|
1930's-present |
|
SHS |
|
Associated
with Prohibition, badly damaged by fire & rebuilt, 2007 |
|
Jennings
Boarding House |
Cutchogue |
Capt Jonathan
Jennings |
1880's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Jewell Farm
House |
Southold |
E F Jewell |
1880's /
1900's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Judd's Hotel |
Southold |
Frank L. Judd |
1870's-1880's |
Main Road &
corner of Youngs Avenue |
SHS |
Southold
Hotel |
Cut up into
pieces and sold, several portions still extant as private homes |
|
Kreutzer Park
Hotel |
Southold |
Mrs Marie
Kreutzer |
c1890's-1919 |
Main Road |
SHS |
Also listed
under name Kientzer |
Moved to
water & converted to a private home by the Lange family |
|
Lake Lodge |
Peconic |
|
|
|
SHS |
|
Associated
with Prohibition |
|
Laura's Cabin
on the Green |
East Marion |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Laurel House |
Laurel |
Miss H L
Fanning |
|
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Laurel House |
Southold |
Mrs George L
Gaffga |
1920's |
|
SHS |
|
|
|
Lehr Farm
House |
Southold |
Martin Lehr |
1900's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Leicht Farm
House |
Southold |
C Leicht |
1900's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Lewis
Boarding House |
Southold |
Mrs Carrie J
Lewis |
1900's |
Main Road |
SHS / SCHS |
|
Later owned
by Cochran family, demolished 1989. |
|
Locust Grove
Hotel |
South
Jamesport |
James L
Downs / E O Downs |
1899-1920? |
South
Jamesport Avenue |
Brooklyn
Eagle |
Waters Edge
Hotel |
New House
100ft from Peconic Bay, partially demolished for the Motel on the Bay |
|
Lyle's Beach
Hotel (or Lyles) |
Fisher's
Island |
Walker &
William Hoes |
1882-1891 |
|
Internet
|
Munnatawket
Hotel |
Rebuilt 1891,
demolished 1926 |
|
MacNish's
Hotel |
New Suffolk |
William McNish/Walter
MacNish / William H. Grant |
c1880's-1900's |
|
SHS |
New Suffolk
Hotel / Grant Hotel |
Collapsed and
demolished |
|
Mallard Inn |
East Marion |
|
1940's-? |
Main Road |
|
|
Located at
the Causeway, burned 1974-1976 |
|
Manaton House |
Greenport |
Mrs W P
Manaton |
1920's |
|
SHS |
|
|
|
Mansion House |
Fisher's
Island |
Edmund &
Walter Ferguson |
1892-1941 |
|
SHS |
|
Partially
demolished c1945 |
|
Mattituck
Harbor Inn |
Mattituck |
Hubert W
Klein / Andrew Barbi / Eugenia Sommerman / Mrs A Esposito / M L Gardoni |
c1880's-1938 |
Breezy Point |
SHS |
|
Destroyed by
fire in 1938 Richaret & Vicing Pamphlet |
|
Mattituck
House |
Mattituck |
Riley
Brothers / William Niederstein / George Blake / Edith Peyton / Carl Dahl
/ GM
Betts / Albert E Dantzig |
1700's-1950's |
Love Lane &
Old Sound Avenue |
SHS / LI
Traveler |
Niederstein's
Mattituck House |
Demolished
1950's |
|
Mattituck
Motel |
Mattituck |
Emilie
Haunstetter / Kelly Navarra |
1950's-present |
Bay Avenue |
SHS |
|
Started out
as the Bay View Cottages c1890's |
|
McCabe Farm
House |
Southold |
M McCabe |
1900's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Meadow Pink
Cottage |
Peconic |
J Ducey |
1900's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Miamogue
Hotel |
South
Jamesport |
I. Seymour
Corwin |
1875-1932 |
South
Jamesport Avenue |
SHS |
|
1st hotel
destroyed by fire in 1895, replacement destroyed by fire in 1932 |
|
Mononotto Inn |
Fisher's
Island |
Maria Hoppes |
1892-1939 |
|
SHS |
|
Demolished
1939 |
|
Moore
Boarding House |
Greenport
|
Mrs C B Moore |
1900's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Moore's hotel |
Southold |
|
|
J W Huntting
property |
Internet
|
|
|
|
Moore's
Tavern |
Southold |
Mrs. Moore |
c1730's-1800's |
Boisseau
Avenue & Main Road |
SHS |
|
One of the
earliest recorded inns, demolished in 1936 |
|
Morse
Boarding House |
South
Jamesport |
B H Morse |
1880's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Mossback
Cabins |
East Marion |
Mossback
family |
|
Main Road |
OHS |
|
Related to
the family of noted painter Charles Henry Miller |
|
Motel on the
Bay |
South
Jamesport |
Bob Patchell |
c1950s-present |
|
SHS |
|
Located on
the site of the former Waters Edge Hotel |
|
Mott's
Bayshore House |
Greenport |
M M Mott |
c1890-1910 |
Main Street |
SHS / Corwin
|
Claudio's
Restaurant |
|
|
Mount
Pleasant House Hotel |
Orient |
William &
Samuel Young / John & Joseph Miller |
1879-1940's |
|
OHS / SHS |
Mount
Pleasant Hotel |
Demolished
1940's |
|
Mrs Albert
Smith Boarding House |
Mattituck |
Mrs Albert
Smith |
|
|
SHS |
|
|
|
Mrs Joseph A
McDonald Boarding House |
Greenport
|
Mrs Joseph
McDonald (Sara) |
|
Ludlum Place |
SHS |
|
|
|
Mrs O Smith
Boarding House |
Greenport |
Mrs O Smith
(widow) |
|
Central
Avenue |
SHS |
|
|
|
Mrs S Davis
Boarding House |
Southold |
Mrs S Davis |
|
|
SHS |
|
|
|
Mrs Seaman
Boarding House |
Greenport |
Mrs Seaman
(Annie?) |
|
Second Street |
SHS |
|
|
|
Mrs Wm Payne
Boarding House |
Greenport |
Mrs William H
Payne |
|
Central
Avenue |
SHS |
|
|
|
Munnatawket
Hotel |
Fisher's
Island |
Edmund &
Walter Ferguson |
1891-1926 |
|
SHS |
Lyle's Beach
Hotel |
Demolished
1926 |
|
Nassau Point
Club Hotel |
Nassau Point |
|
1903-1928 |
|
SHS |
|
Burned June
18, 1928 |
|
New Suffolk
Hotel |
New Suffolk |
William MacNish/Walter
MacNish / William H. Grant |
c1880's-1900's |
|
SHS |
MacNish's
Hotel / Grant Hotel |
Collapsed and
demolished |
|
Niederstein's
Mattituck House |
Mattituck |
William
Niederstein |
1700's-1950's |
Love Lane &
Old Sound Avenue |
SHS |
Mattituck
House |
Demolished
1950's |
|
North Fork
Motel |
Southold |
Laasko
Brothers |
1950's |
Rte 48 & Old
North Road |
Corwin / SHS |
North Fork
Condominiums |
Two story, 43
rooms |
|
Occidental
House |
Greenport |
George
Davis / Frank Smith / Lewis Laws |
1895 |
|
LI Traveler |
|
|
|
Old Glory
House |
Greenport |
Frank J
Claudio |
1900's |
Main Road |
Corwin |
|
|
|
Old Mill |
Mattituck |
Adolf
Magdefrau |
|
|
SHS |
|
Associated
with Prohibition, at one time it had guest rooms |
|
Old Orchard
Farm |
Southold |
G R Jennings |
1900's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
O'Neill
Cottage |
Southold |
Hannah
O'Neill |
|
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Orient Inn
Bed & Breakfast |
Orient |
Joan Turturro
& Howard Leshaw |
1990's?-present |
Main Road |
SHS |
|
|
|
Orient Point
House |
Orient |
Jonathan F
Latham / Merry Parsons |
1834-1950's |
Main Road |
SHS / OHS |
Orient Point
Inn |
Demolished
1980's-1990's |
|
Orient Point
Inn |
Orient |
Jonathan F
Latham / Merry Parsons |
1834-1950's |
Main Road |
SHS / OHS |
Orient Point
House |
Demolished
1980's-1990's |
|
Paradise
Point |
Southold |
George W
Bullock (Bullick) |
|
|
SHS / OHS |
|
|
|
Paragon Hotel |
Greenport |
J J Burns |
|
|
SHS |
|
|
|
Paumanok Inn |
Southold |
George F
Hummel / W J Palmer |
c1910-1925 |
Lighthouse
Road |
SHS |
Soundview
House |
Demolished |
|
Payne
Boarding House |
Southold |
B T Payne / B J
Payne |
1900's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Peakin's
Tavern |
Orient |
John Peakin |
1700's |
|
OHS |
|
|
|
Peconic Bay
House |
Greenport |
John Webb / F B
Goldsmith / L O Richardson / Augustus Smith |
1845-1900's |
Third Street
& Front Street |
SHS / Corwin
|
Peconic House |
Demolished
before 1930 |
|
Peconic House |
Greenport |
John Webb / F B
Goldsmith / L O Richardson / Augustus Smith |
1845-1900's |
Third Street
& Front Street |
SHS / Corwin
|
Peconic Bay
House |
Demolished
before 1930 |
|
Peconic Park
Hotel |
Nassau Point |
Mr. Wilson |
1883 |
|
SHS |
|
* Proposed,
but never constructed |
|
Phillips
Boarding House |
Southold |
G W Phillips |
1880's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Pipes Neck
House |
Greenport |
Mrs A C
Corwin / Mary Holman / Isadora Judge |
1823-1940's |
|
OHS |
|
Original
burned in 1912 and was rebuilt |
|
PJ Claudio
|
Greenport |
PJ Claudio |
|
|
SHS |
|
|
|
Pleasant View
Cottages |
Greenport |
|
1950's-present |
Seventh
Street |
SHS |
|
|
|
Point O'View
Inn |
Southold |
J. Payne / Anna
Walsh / Polliwater |
1920's-1940's |
54775 Main
Road |
SHS |
|
Currently a
private home |
|
Prince
Boarding House |
Peconic |
G H Prince |
1900's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Prince
Boarding House |
Southold |
B L Prince |
1880's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Quintessentials Bed & Breakfast |
East Marion |
Sylvia Daley |
1994-present |
|
SHS |
|
|
|
Reeves
Boarding House |
Greenport |
Mrs W W
Reeves |
1880's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Richmond Farm
House |
Southold |
HC Richmond |
1900's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Riverside
Hotel |
South
Jamesport |
C W Conklin |
|
|
LI Traveler |
Brown House |
|
|
Roarke
Boarding House |
Southold |
P Roarke |
1880's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Robinson
Boarding House |
South
Jamesport |
J F Robinson |
1880's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Rocky Bluff Inn |
Greenport |
Mrs. Charles Herman |
c. 1906 |
North Road |
PC |
|
No longer extant |
|
Rooming House |
Southold |
Etta
Payne / Catheryn McCabe |
|
|
Murphy |
|
Ms McCabe
also housekeeper to Priests at St Patricks Church |
|
S Tuthill
Boarding House |
Mattituck |
|
|
|
SHS |
|
|
|
Santorini
Beachcomber |
Cutchogue |
Santorini
family |
1995-present |
Duck Pond
Road |
SHS |
Beachcomber
Resort Motel |
|
|
Seward House |
Orient |
|
1870's-1886 |
Main Road |
OHS |
Edward
Brothers House |
Currently a
private home |
|
Shady Point
Hotel |
Mattituck |
W S Du Bois |
1895 |
|
LI Traveler
Internet |
|
|
|
Shorecrest
Bed & Breakfast |
Greenport |
Susan & John
Barnes |
c2001-present |
Rte 48 |
SHS |
|
|
|
Silver Sands
Motel |
Greenport |
|
c1958-present |
Silvermere
Road |
SHS |
|
Added to the
Silvermere Bungalows site |
|
Silvermere
Bungalows |
Greenport |
|
c1930's-present |
Silvermere
Road |
SHS |
|
Later joined
by the Silver Sands Motel |
|
Sound Shore
Motel |
Greenport |
Jack & Irving
Levin |
1952-present |
Rte 48 |
SHS / Corwin |
Soundview
Motel, Soundview Inn |
Still
operated by the Levin family |
|
Sound Shore
Resort Motel |
Greenport |
Jack & Irving
Levin |
1952-present |
Rte 48 |
SHS / Corwin |
Soundview
Motel, Soundview Inn |
Still
operated by the Levin family |
|
Sound View
Farm House |
Cutchogue |
PJ Mahoney |
|
|
Brooklyn
Eagle |
|
|
|
Soundview
House |
Southold |
George F
Hummel / W J Palmer |
c1910-1925 |
Lighthouse
Road |
SHS |
Paumanok Inn |
Demolished |
|
Soundview Inn |
Greenport |
Jack & Irving
Levin |
1952-present |
Rte 48 |
SHS / Corwin |
Sound Shore
Resort Motel, Soundview Inn |
Still
operated by the Levin family |
|
Soundview
Motel |
Greenport |
Jack & Irving
Levin |
1952-present |
Rte 48 |
SHS / Corwin |
Soundview
Motel, Sound Shore Resort Hotel |
Still
operated by the Levin family |
|
Southold
Beach Motel |
Southold |
Helmut Haas |
c1955-present |
Rte 48,
Southold |
SHS |
Southold Town
Beach Motel |
Sold to Amy
Uyanik in 2005 |
|
Southold
Hotel |
Southold |
William H
Wells / Joseph A Wells / Theodore Hoinkis / Frank L Judd / William W Sands
/ W
Bassett / Charles Hannaburg / Abram W Kent / J Stephens 1887 |
1830's-1920's |
Main Road &
corner of Youngs Avenue |
SHS |
Judd's Hotel |
Cut up into
pieces and sold, several portions still extant as private homes |
|
Southold Inn |
Southold |
|
c1910-present |
Main Road |
SHS |
Sunrise
Inn / Southold Inn / La Gazelle / Coeur Des Vignes |
Currently
North Fork Table & Inn |
|
Southold Town
Beach Motel |
Southold |
Helmut Haas |
c1955-present |
Rte 48,
Southold |
SHS |
Southold
Beach Motel |
Sold to Amy
Uyanik in 2005 |
|
Sparks
Boarding House |
South
Jamesport |
Sparks |
1880's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Spruce Park
Boarding House |
Southold |
Israel Peck |
1850's |
Wells Avenue
& Main Road |
SHS |
Oaklawn |
Demolished
April 1966 |
|
Star House |
Greenport |
Manuel
Claudio |
c1910 |
|
SHS |
|
|
|
Star Inn &
Cottages |
East Marion |
|
c1950's-present |
Main Road |
|
|
Across from
East Marion Community Church |
|
Sterling
Harbor House Bed & Breakfast |
Greenport |
|
In operation |
Sterling
Street |
SHS |
|
|
|
Sterling
House Bed & Breakfast |
Greenport |
|
In operation |
Bay Avenue |
SHS |
|
|
|
Sterlington
Hotel |
Greenport |
F B
Thornhill / G P Salmon |
1894-1980? |
Third Street |
SHS |
Burr Hotel
|
Presently
(2009) a restaurant |
|
Suffolk House |
New Suffolk |
Henry Burns |
|
|
SHS |
|
|
|
Sunrise Hotel |
Southold |
|
c1910-present |
Main Road |
SHS |
Sunrise
Inn / Southold Inn / La Gazelle / Coeur Des Vignes |
Currently
North Fork Table & Inn |
|
Sunrise Inn |
Southold |
|
c1910-present |
Main Road |
SHS |
Sunrise
Hotel / Southold Inn / La Gazelle / Coeur Des Vignes |
Currently
North Fork Table & Inn |
|
Sunrise Trail
House |
Southold |
V & I Fitall |
|
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Sunset Motel |
Greenport |
Molin
Brothers / Vera Molin / Donna Levin |
c1960-present |
Rte 48 |
SHS |
|
Presently
(2009) operated by Martha Levin |
|
The Country
House Bed & Breakfast |
Cutchogue |
Noreen &
Martin Frey |
In operation |
Skunk Lane |
SHS |
|
|
|
The Harvest
Inn |
Peconic |
Darolyn &
Christopher ? |
2002-present |
Main Road |
SHS |
|
|
|
The Morning
Glory Bed & Breakfast |
Greenport |
Renate &
Klaus Wilhelm |
2004-present |
Main Street |
SHS |
|
House built
in 1822 |
|
The
Rhinelander Bed & Breakfast |
Cutchogue |
Gisela
Morchel |
1996-present |
Main Road |
SHS |
|
|
|
The Victorian
Lady |
Greenport |
|
In operation |
Bay Avenue |
SHS |
|
|
|
Tillinghast
Boarding House |
Southold |
E S
Tillinghast |
1880's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Timson
Boarding House |
Greenport |
Mrs James
Timson |
1880's |
|
SCHS |
|
Possibly same
as Timson Hotel |
|
Timson Hotel |
Greenport |
James Timson |
1869-1891 |
Main Street |
SHS / Corwin |
|
Later George
Flack decorating & Everett Warner Picture Frames |
|
Top 'O the
Mornin' Bed & Breakfast |
Cutchogue |
|
In operation |
Main Road |
SHS |
|
|
|
Townsend
Boarding House |
Greenport |
Mrs S H
Townsend |
1880's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Townsend
Manor Inn |
Greenport |
Lillian Cook
Townsend |
1925-present |
Main Street |
SHS / OHS |
|
Built as a
residence for George Cogswell |
|
Tuthill
Boarding House |
Cutchogue |
H H Tuthill |
1880's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Tuthill
Boarding House |
Cutchogue |
Ira B Tuthill |
1880's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Tuthill
Boarding House |
Cutchogue |
G Tuthill |
1880's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Tuthill
Boarding House |
Cutchogue |
H B Tuthill |
1880's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Tuthill
Boarding House |
Cutchogue |
Mrs J G
Tuthill |
1880's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Tuthill
Boarding House |
Cutchogue |
O H Tuthill |
1880's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Tuthill
Boarding House |
Mattituck |
Mrs Mavin
Tuthill |
1880's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Tuthill
Boarding House |
Southold |
W H Tuthill |
1880's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Tyler
Boarding House |
South
Jamesport |
H L Tyler |
1900's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Vail Boarding
House |
Greenport |
G H Vail |
|
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Vail Boarding
House |
Southold |
W B Vail |
1880's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Victoria
Motel & Cottages |
Southold |
|
c1950's-1984 |
Main Bayview
Road |
SHS |
|
Demolished in
1984 and replaced by "The Cove Condominiums" |
|
Vienna Hotel |
Greenport |
Stephan Cvija |
c1900-1960's |
Front Street |
SHS |
Hotel
Greenport Helen's Hotel |
Currently the
Rhumbline Restaurant |
|
Village House |
Orient |
Jeremiah Vail |
1880's-? |
Village Lane |
OHS |
Village Hotel |
Currently
owned by Oysterponds Historical Society |
|
Vintage Bed &
Breakfast |
Cutchogue |
Jeanne & Lou
Genovese |
2000-present |
Skunk Lane |
SHS |
|
|
|
Waters Edge
Hotel |
South
Jamesport |
E O Downs |
1920-1940's? |
|
SHS-
Riverhead Halcyon days |
Locust Grove
Hotel |
|
|
White Lions
Inn |
Greenport |
|
|
|
SHS |
|
|
|
White
Shingles Boarding House |
Orient |
Hortense Knox |
1930's-1953 |
Main Road |
OHS |
|
Currently a
private home |
|
Wiggins
Boarding House |
Greenport |
MV Wiggins |
|
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Willow
Cottage |
Southold |
Mrs E Davis |
1900's |
|
SCHS |
|
|
|
Windamere
Boarding House |
Mattituck |
HW Klein |
1900's |
|
SCHS / Internet |
|
|
|
Winward Shore
Motel & Cottage |
Greenport |
|
|
|
SHS |
|
|
|
Wyandank
Hotel |
Greenport |
Charles C
Wright / S P Conklin / Ansel V Young / F J CorwinHenry Stratton |
1840-1968 |
Railroad
Avenue |
SHS / OHS |
Wyandank
House |
Demolished
1968. David Taylor |
|
Yetter's
hotel |
Greenport |
John Yetter |
|
|
Internet
|
|
|
|
Youngs House |
Greenport |
Mrs L J Young |
|
|
SHS |
|
|
